Hobie Brown, Emotional Preparation, and the Art of Great Dialogue
Nearly all of Hobie’s dialogue is written with his goal - protecting and preparing Miles for Miguel’s abuse - in mind, even if it may not be obvious at first watch.
Here’s an unhinged breakdown where I over-analyze literally every one of Hobie’s lines and explain how every sentence was written to contribute directly to Miles’ radicalization.
Hobie has around 10 minutes screentime total, but for the sake of introductions and this analysis, let’s start at the end of the battle, and the beginning of the quantum hole.
Starting with his first line in the scene:
“I don’t follow orders. Neither does he.”
All morals considered, Hobie doesn’t seem like the type to speak for someone who can speak for themselves - he’s a punk after all.
But here, he speaks for Miles. This line serves to tell Miles ‘I don’t respect them, why should you?’, but funnily enough, it can also be a point to Jess, as if to say 'Miles isn’t interested.’ - even if he is.
“Bit much, innit?”
While, Hobie and Mile’s next interaction is their exchange in the elevator, the scene leads to Mile’s introduction to the Society. Miles gawks at the lobby, obviously impressed. Gwen affirms this awe, telling him ’this is just the lobby.’
However, Hobie feels the need to chime in. His next dialogue 'Bit much, innit?’ is a subtle nudge to Miles that the society is not a place to be in awe off. It’s a spectacle, one that’s a bit overdone. Knowing Miles now sees Hobie as cool, Hobie makes it known - he sees the Society as uncool.
“Gwendy, How much have you told him? About his place in all this? Maybe not enough.”
'So what happened about that small elite strike-team?’ - 'Most of these are part time.’ This is by far one of Hobie’s more interesting lines, and I wrote about it here. But in short, this is Hobie’s soft but direct confrontation of Gwen. After Gwen lies to Miles in front of him, Hobie immediately asks how much Gwen has revealed to him. And when she tries to play it off, he openly says 'Maybe that’s not enough.’ He’s not angry with Gwen, but he is disappointed, which in turn motivates him to have his discussion with Miles.
This is fantastic and so confusing. So many songs I had a strong recognization for, and then some lines I had none. I really wanted to sing more than one of each. Wild.
from the notes (thank you to @ yetanotherplayer): Where is the Love Mashup Our Song – Taylor Swift, Angel – Shaggy, Whatever You Like – T.I., Chicken Fried – Zac Brown Band, Love the Way You Lie – Eminem, Feathered Indians – Tyler Childers (yikes), Hey Ya – Outkast, How You Remind Me – Nickelback, Ocean Avenue – Yellowcard, Tubthumping – Chumbawhumba, Sweetest Girl (Dollar Bill) – Wyclef Jean, It’s a Great Day to be Alive – Travis Tritt, Irreplaceable – Beyo, I’ll Name the Dogs – Blake Shelton, BBQ Stain – Tim McGraw, Shape of You – Ed Sheeran, Self Conscious – Kanye West, Country Grammar (Hot Shit) – Nelly, You’re Beautiful – James Blunt, Soul Sister – Train, Every Morning – Sugar Ray, Just A Friend – Biz Markie, Welcome to the Black Parade – My Chemical Romance, I’m Like a Bird – Nelly Furtado, Crazy Bitch – Buckcherry, I Wanna Talk About Me – Toby Keith, Changes – Tupac , Bad Day – Daniel Powter, Scars – Papa Roach.
